Home arrow Newsletters arrow Latest Newsletters arrow Texas Law Alert - Summer 2008

Articles

Texas Law Alert - Summer 2008 Issue


LAWNMOWER ACCIDENTS AND INJURIES

            As the days get longer and hotter and as the grass starts to grow, more people will be taking out their mowers and cutting their lawns. However, it is easy to forget just how dangerous mowers can be. Every year, mowers are responsible for thousands of injuries, many to children.

            The injury rate with mowers (riding mowers in particular) is very high, with 663,000 people needing medical attention due to mower injuries between 1996 and 2004, and with an average injury rate among owners of riding mowers of 2.6 injuries per 1,000 users. It is important to remember that most people, on average over the course of a year, use their mowers only once or twice each month. This means that, per use, mowers are far more dangerous than many other kinds of products, including cars and even guns.

            Injuries caused by lawnmowers can be very serious. Many injuries are the result of people being exposed to the whirling mower blades. These blades, designed to cut grass, can also efficiently cut humans, and can result in the loss of fingers, toes, and even entire limbs. Some people suffer eye injuries and blunt trauma when debris, such as rocks and sticks, is shot out of the mower’s discharge chute at 170 miles per hour; others are burned on exposed engine parts and mower decks, which can get very hot when a mower is in use. 

Backover Accidents

            The most serious source of lawnmower injuries is the so‑called “backover accident.” As the name suggests, a backover accident occurs when a mowers operator backs over himself or someone else. Backover accidents alone injure almost 600 children per year. Although all mower accidents have the potential to be serious, backover accidents are often the worst because the operator does not see a child behind him, and rolls the mower entirely over the child.

            A few years ago, the lawnmower industry voluntarily placed a safety feature on mowers, called the “no‑mow‑in‑reverse” feature. This feature automatically disconnects the mower’s blades when the mower is put into reverse, in theory eliminating the possibility of a backover accident. The problem is that the mower industry also added a feature that allows mower operators to override this safety feature and continue to mow in reverse. It is also possible to mow in reverse even if the operator does not override the feature, for example, when the mower is mowing uphill and the gears slip, causing the mower to roll backwards—in such cases, the no‑mow‑in‑reverse feature often does not work. 

In the Courts

            Lawsuits over the dangerous condition of mowers have had mixed results. In several federal cases, the courts have found that warnings to keep children away from the mower were adequate and that the mower manufacturer was therefore not liable for not installing a no‑mow‑in‑reverse feature or for allowing it to be overridden. Lawsuits in state courts have been more favorable, with juries several times faulting the mower manufacturer for the lack of some safety feature.

            Many suggestions have been made to increase mower safety, including a reduction in the top speed that a mower can travel while going in reverse and a reduction in the amount of time that it takes the blades to stop spinning from five seconds to three seconds. Some have pushed for improved warnings, for moving the override switch to the back of the mower so that the operator would have to look behind him if he wanted to use it, or even for the complete elimination of the no‑mow‑in‑reverse override. To date, the mower industry has resisted all of these changes, and the government has failed to act to increase mower safety.

            If you have been injured by a lawnmower, you might have a products liability suit against the manufacturer and others. Products liability suits tend to be complex: The defendant usually fights such claims very vigorously, because even one successful claim could open the door to hundreds or thousands of other claims. These lawsuits also tend to be highly technical, requiring detailed evidence from design and manufacturing experts about how the product was made incorrectly, how it could have been done differently, and how all of these failures caused the injury.

            It is tough to go it alone. Call us. We look forward to discussing your case and your options. 

 

WE APPRECIATE YOU!

            Thank you for choosing our firm for your legal needs. We hope that you will continue to count on us when you need legal help. We are just a phone call away.

            We also appreciate the trust that you have placed in us by referring your friends, family, and associates to us for legal services. Thanks! 

 

YOUR TEEN IS READY TO DRIVE?

MAKE THAT PROSPECT LESS FRIGHTENING

            So your baby is all grown up (or thinks he is) and wants to get his driver’s license. While having a teen on your auto policy is likely to raise the price of your insurance, there are things you can do to increase the chances that your teen will be a safe driver.

            First, set a good example. If you speed, tailgate, and drive aggressively, your teen probably will also. Relax, slow down, and show your child how a safe driver operates.

            Insist that your teen wear his seat belt. Texas has a law requiring seat‑belt use, and wearing a seat belt has been proven to be the best way to prevent injuries in an accident. Make sure that your teen wears his seat belt every time he drives.

            Many teenagers think that they are 10 feet tall and bulletproof, and that nothing bad can happen to them. We know better, so set clear limits. Studies have shown that teens are more easily distracted than more experienced drivers are, so limit the number of distractions.

            You can restrict the number of people that your teen is allowed to have in the car or prohibit him from using his mobile phone or eating while driving. Nighttime is a more dangerous time to drive, so set a “driving curfew,” a time by which the car has to be back in the garage. Drinking and driving (which is not safe for any driver, and is also against the law) must absolutely be prohibited.

            Make sure that your teen understands that driving is a privilege. The ability to drive means that the teen is getting closer to adulthood, but being an adult has serious obligations. Be certain that your teen understands that driving is dangerous, not just for him but for the other drivers with whom he shares the road. Impress upon him that unsafe behavior or the failure to obey your rules means that you will take the keys.

            Finally, check for insurance discounts. Although insurance for teen drivers is very expensive, some insurers offer certain discounts. For example, some companies give discounts if your child is on the honor roll. Others offer discounts if the child completes an approved safe driving course.

            Taking these steps can help your teen driver grow into a safe driver. 

 

LAWNMOWER SAFETY TIPS

            Although lawnmowers are very dangerous, they can be used safely. Follow these tips to reduce the chances of injuring someone while mowing the lawn:

  • When you mow, make sure that the area is clear, especially of children. NEVER allow children to play where you are mowing.


    Inspect the yard before you start, and remove debris. A mower can shoot a stick or rock out of the chute at 170 miles per hour, causing injuries. Obstructions in the lawn can also damage the mower itself.


    Inspect your mower before you begin, in order to make sure that it is in good condition and safe to operate.


    Do not mow up and down hills, as the mower can roll backwards. Instead, mow across a hill. NEVER mow while going in reverse.


    Do not mow wet grass. Operators can slip on wet grass, losing control of the mower.


    Wear the proper safety equipment, including long pants, long sleeves, sturdy shoes, eye protection, and ear protection.


    NEVER put your hand anywhere near the blades of a mower that is running, even if you think that the blades are disengaged. Always turn the mower off first.


    Do not refuel the mower in an enclosed space (such as a shed) or when the engine is hot, because the gasoline could explode. Wait for the engine to cool before refueling, and do so outside.

     

THE IMPORTANCE OF PRESERVING EVIDENCE

            Regardless of the kind of case you have, every lawsuit is the same in one way: The evidence must support your claim. This means that if you suspect you have a claim, you should take steps to preserve the evidence that could be critical in supporting your case.

            It is said that a picture is worth a thousand words, and this is especially true in a lawsuit. If you have been hurt in a car accident, take photos of the car you were in, the scene, and, if possible, your injuries. Documents can also be evidence: Receipts, medical records, product instructions, accident reports, and the like can all be used to prove your claims.

            Evidence is especially important in products liability cases, where someone is hurt by a defective product. Keep the product in the condition that it was in when the injury occurred and, if it is not in your possession (such as a car in a wrecker yard), take steps to secure it. There are reports of defendants trying to buy the defective product so that they can destroy it.

            Sooner is better than later. A picture of the accident scene taken the day after a collision is worth more than one taken a year later. A picture of your bruises taken soon after you were injured will tell more than pictures of the same bruises once they have begun to heal.

            When you hire a lawyer to represent you, give him all of the evidence you have saved. This will help make your case and get you the compensation you deserve. 

 

INSURERS MAKE RECORD PROFITS—AT YOUR EXPENSE

            Insurers in America have posted record profits of $62 billion in 2007. These profits are not a fluke: Insurers have made almost $170 billion in profits since Hurricane Katrina, and about $235 billion since 2002.

            These profits are the product of a combination of higher premiums and smaller payments. In fact, insurers routinely refuse to pay covered claims and use unfair claims and settlement practices to increase profits, harming policyholders who have paid for coverage.

            The next time you hear insurers lamenting poor profits and blaming greedy lawyers for increases in premiums, remember who it is that has all of the money. Unfortunately, if you want a fair shake from an insurer, you have to hire a lawyer to help you, which is why people with lawyers regularly recover far more from insurance companies than people without lawyers do.

 

CASE BY CASE

Workplace Safety Violations Cost Employer

            A jury recently returned a $3.7 million verdict against the employer of a man who was seriously injured when he fell down an open elevator shaft.

            The worker (who, ironically, was responsible for safety at the construction site) fell because the rails intended to keep people from falling down the shaft had been partially disassembled. The evidence showed that one side of the rails had been unscrewed from the supports and, when the worker leaned on the rails, they gave way and he fell.

            The fall caused the worker to break several ribs, his shoulder, and his elbow. His injuries were so serious that he could not move, and he had to be rescued from the elevator shaft by a crane.

            At trial, the employer blamed the worker, saying that the worker had given permission for the rails to be loosened to allow another company to do some work. The employer also claimed that the rails were obviously not attached and that it was the worker’s fault for not noticing. However, these claims were undermined by another worker, who testified that the rails still looked as if they were properly attached.

            The jury ruled against the employer. It awarded the worker over $3 million for his injuries and loss of earnings, and his wife almost $700,000 because of the injuries suffered by her husband.

            Workplace safety is important, and verdicts such as these play an important role in ensuring that employers have the proper incentive to protect their workers.